A Lutheran response to Joel Peter’s booklet,
“Scripture Alone? 21 Reasons to Reject Sola Scriptura”
Sola Scriptura is one of the “solas” of the Reformation of the 16th century. It was not, and it is not, an obsolete teaching or doctrine. Nor was it a novel invention of Luther.
Sola Scriptura remains today as one of the “solas” of Reformation churches the world over, not because it was a teaching of Dr. Martin Luther, but because it is the very teaching of Scripture itself. Because this is so, it is necessary to properly distinguish what Sola Scriptura is from what it is not, especially in light of current attacks on said doctrine. The charge that Sola Scriptura is a “new creation” or that it has no basis in the church is not according to the text of Scripture itself.
In responding to the charges made by Joel Peters against Sola Scriptura in his little booklet entitled, Scripture Alone? 21 Reasons to Reject Sola Scriptura, I wish to clarify what is true from what is not. I also wish to defend Sola Scriptura, not only from Roman Catholic misrepresentation, but also from other similar characterizations.
In the next section, I will define Sola Scriptura, as well as distinguish what is regarded authoritative in much of Protestantism and the Roman Catholic Church. I use the term Protestantism, not in its historical sense, but in its general usage today, meaning non-Roman Catholic churches of the Western church (in distinction from the church of the East, the Orthodox).
Some might genuinely ask if such an apologetic in response to 21 Reasons To Reject Sola Scriptura is necessary. I believe it is, not so much because everyone accepts Peters’ claims, but because a number of his claims against Sola Scriptura are accepted as true by many Roman Catholics, Protestants, and nonChristians alike.
Filed under: Apologetics, Bible-Holy Scripture, Christian Denominations & Fellowship, Law & Gospel-Rightly Dividing the Word of Truth, Luther & The Reformation, Lutheran Confessions, Reviews (Books, articles, etc.), Theology & Doctrine | Tagged: Bible, Catholic, Peters, Protestantism, Scriptura, Sola |